Short answer: For an injury (CTP) claim, fault is first decided by the CTP insurer of the vehicle alleged to be at fault, based on the evidence. If you disagree, it is negotiated, raised at the compulsory conference, and if necessary decided by a court applying the law of negligence and the Queensland road rules. Queensland has no official "fault determination rules" for CTP injury claims. A police charge or infringement notice is strong evidence, but it doesn't decide the claim on its own.
Who decides fault?
- The CTP insurer decides whether it accepts liability, fully, partly or not at all, after receiving your Notice of Accident Claim Form.
- If you disagree, the dispute is negotiated and can be raised at the compulsory conference. MAIC says that if a dispute about liability cannot be resolved through discussion or at a compulsory conference, it has to go to court.
- A court decides fault on the balance of probabilities.
Vehicle damage claims are separate. Property insurers handle them under their own policies, and how they treat fault doesn't decide your injury claim.
What evidence is used?
- Police report and QP number. Record what police were told and whether anyone was charged or fined.
- Dashcam footage, yours or from other vehicles, buses or nearby businesses. Save it quickly; many cameras overwrite within hours or days.
- Photos of vehicle damage, final positions, skid marks, debris, traffic lights, signs and lane markings.
- Witness statements. Get names and phone numbers at the scene if you can.
- CCTV from shops, service stations or council cameras (ask early; it's often kept for a short time).
- Vehicle damage patterns, which show the point and angle of impact.
- The road rules. The Transport Operations (Road Use Management—Road Rules) Regulation 2009 (Qld) sets out duties such as keeping a safe following distance, giving way at intersections, and obeying traffic lights and signs.
- Expert evidence in disputed cases, such as accident reconstruction.
Common situations
- Rear-end collisions: the following driver must keep a sufficient distance to stop safely, so fault usually lies with the driver behind. See Rear-end collision injury claims.
- Intersections and failure to give way: decided by who had the right of way under the signs, signals and give-way rules.
- Lane changes and merging: the driver changing lanes must give way to vehicles already in the lane.
- Pedestrians and cyclists: drivers must take care around vulnerable road users, but a pedestrian or cyclist's own conduct can be considered. See Pedestrians hit by vehicles and Cyclists hit by cars.
- Both drivers partly at fault: responsibility is shared, and each injured person's compensation is reduced only by their own share. See When the insurer says you were partly at fault.
What if the insurer denies liability?
- Ask for the reasons in writing.
- Provide any further evidence: footage, witness statements, the police report.
- If the insurer maintains its position, liability can be argued at the compulsory conference and, if needed, in court within the limitation period (generally 3 years from the accident).
Time limits keep running while fault is disputed. See How long after a car accident can you claim?.
To arrange a first appointment, call 07 3519 5679 or see Car accident lawyers Brisbane.
Frequently asked questions
Are there fault determination rules in Queensland? Not for CTP injury claims. Fault is decided on the evidence and the law of negligence, using the road rules as a guide. Property insurers may apply their own approach to vehicle damage claims, but that doesn't decide an injury claim.
Does the police report decide who was at fault? No, but it is important evidence. A charge or fine against the other driver often supports a claim. The absence of one doesn't mean they weren't at fault.
The other driver admitted fault at the scene. Is that enough? It helps, so note exactly what was said and who heard it. The insurer still looks at all the evidence.
What if no one saw the accident? Fault can still be proved from the vehicle damage, the road layout, footage and expert evidence.
Sources
- Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994 (Qld) — legislation.qld.gov.au
- Motor Accident Insurance Commission, Frequently asked questions — maic.qld.gov.au
- Motor Accident Insurance Commission, What to do after an accident — maic.qld.gov.au
- Transport Operations (Road Use Management—Road Rules) Regulation 2009 (Qld) — legislation.qld.gov.au

