Short answer: Yes, you can usually still claim. In Queensland, if you were partly responsible for an accident or for your injuries, your compensation is reduced by your share of responsibility. The claim doesn't end. This is called contributory negligence. MAIC confirms that a person who was partly at fault "can still make a claim, but the amount of compensation you receive may be reduced".
Only a person who was totally at fault, or injured in an accident where no one was at fault, cannot claim under the CTP scheme. (Catastrophic injuries may still be covered by the National Injury Insurance Scheme. See Catastrophic injuries and NIISQ.)
How contributory negligence works
The question is whether you failed to take reasonable care for your own safety, and whether that failure contributed to the accident or to your injuries. If it did, the court (or the insurer, when negotiating) reduces damages by a percentage it considers just and equitable.
Example: if your claim is valued at a given amount and you are found 20% responsible, you receive 80% of that amount.
In rare cases a reduction can be 100%, which defeats the claim.
Common arguments insurers raise
- Not wearing a seatbelt. The argument is that the injuries would have been less serious with a seatbelt. The reduction depends on whether the seatbelt would actually have made a difference to the injuries, which is often a medical question.
- Not wearing a helmet (motorcyclists, cyclists, scooter riders), for head injuries.
- Speed or position on the road, for example a rider filtering, or a driver going slightly over the limit before being hit.
- Pedestrians crossing against a signal or away from a crossing.
- Travelling with a driver you knew was affected by alcohol or drugs. The Civil Liability Act 2003 creates presumptions of contributory negligence where the injured person was intoxicated, or relied on a driver they knew was intoxicated.
- Not keeping a proper lookout, for example at intersections.
An argument isn't the same as a finding. The insurer has to support it with evidence, and you can respond with your own: the police report, photos, dashcam footage, witness statements and expert opinion.
What you can do
- Don't accept a percentage on the spot. An insurer's early view on fault is a negotiating position.
- Gather the evidence: the QP number and police report, photos, dashcam footage, witness details, and the road layout (signage, lights, lane markings).
- Get medical evidence on whether the alleged failure (for example, no seatbelt) actually changed your injuries.
- Respond in writing to the insurer's liability decision.
- If agreement can't be reached, contributory negligence is argued at the compulsory conference, and ultimately decided by a court.
See How fault is decided after a car accident in Queensland.
To arrange a first appointment, call 07 3519 5679 or see Car accident lawyers Brisbane.
Frequently asked questions
Can I claim if I was partially at fault for the accident? Yes. Your compensation is reduced by your share of responsibility, but you can still claim.
How much is compensation reduced for not wearing a seatbelt? There is no fixed percentage. It depends on whether a seatbelt would have reduced your injuries, and by how much, on the evidence in your case.
Can I claim if both drivers were at fault? Yes. Responsibility can be shared between the drivers, and each can claim against the other vehicle's CTP insurer for the share that wasn't their fault. Passengers can claim against both insurers.
I was 100% at fault. Can I claim? Not under the CTP scheme, which covers people injured by someone else's fault. If your injuries are catastrophic, see Catastrophic injuries and NIISQ. Other options can include income protection or TPD cover through superannuation.
Sources
- Motor Accident Insurance Commission, Can I claim? — maic.qld.gov.au
- Civil Liability Act 2003 (Qld), ss 23, 24 (contributory negligence), 47–49 (intoxication) — legislation.qld.gov.au
- Law Reform Act 1995 (Qld), s 10 (apportionment for contributory negligence) — legislation.qld.gov.au

